Sunday, 16 March 2014

Sarah Stein, the apostle of Matisse

Portrait of Sarah Stein, by Matisse (1916)
Source: www.reproduction-gallery.com
I make no secret of my love for Matisse. But no matter how madly in love with him I often find myself to be, I stop for a second and reflect, in the midst of my maddest admiration: Would I have known that Matisse existed had he not been loved by others before? Would I have a taste of his talent had not others promoted him when what was to be promoted was haunted by the scarecrow of novelty?
In the first years of the twentieth century, in Paris, Matisse was well planted in the circle of artists who painted their way towards fame and did their best to acquire notoriety. Like all the other artists living and working at the time, he frequented the circles of various art enthusiasts, dealers and promoters. Matisse was very well acquainted with the Stein family, in whose house at 27 Rue de Fleurus (less than a mile away from the Jardin du Luxembourg), things of crucial importance to the world of art were discussed, where deals were struck and history was written under the hands of the famous Gertrude (eventually turned into one of the most influential writers of the century to come) and her sister Sarah (a genius who, at her apogee, decided to turn his career around and dedicate her life to Christian Science).

The Stein family, circa 1905. Gertrude and Sarah
(second and fourth in the background), were the most powerful women
in the bohemian world of art enthusiasts that populated Paris
at the beginning of the twentieth century.
Source: www.3.bp.blogspot.com
In their house, where artists came and went at rates that would make any art historian envious, a question was constantly asked: who was the greatest among the favourites? Matisse or Picasso? This is, as we well know, a question never quite resolved in the minds of many. Not in mine, though, to be sure. I know who my favourite is, and I am willing to go with him till the end of my days. But then and there, in the Paris at the dawn of the twentieth century, when things were not well established, and when both Matisse and Picasso were relying almost exclusively on their ability to generate contradiction and intrigue, things were not so clear-cut as they are to me now.
In the Stein family, Gertrude was for Picasso, while Sarah was all for Matisse. We have the testimony of Harriet Lane Levy, who, in her little book titled Paris Portraits, gives the world a glimpse of the extent to which the fame of Matisse was decided through the sheer power of will which animated Sarah Stein.
Harriet Lane Levy, Paris Portraits:
Stories of Picasso, Matisse,
Gertrude Stein, and Their Circle
Gertrude was so adamant about her tastes that she scorned anything else, like a hurricane levelling all geographical differences of a landscape. Because of this force, which had alone the ability to establish Picasso as the utmost master, without Sarah Stein there may never have been a taste for Matisse. She was a Matisse crusader who carried the cross and sword of her faith with pride and persuasiveness. Without her, we would have probably had a century of art dominated exclusively by Picasso.
The will to power found in Gertrude’s influence would have sufficed to give the Spaniard the advantage of the best start. But power was equal on the other side. Fighting the lack of understanding of the others by means of her extraordinary persuasiveness, Sarah Stein subjugated to her drive the will of hoards of undecided amateurs. Harriet Lane Levy, who, like many others, liked Picasso best, decided on admiring Matisse only because she could not put up with the force of Sarah’s argument. And, by the looks of it, she was not the only one to have experienced the transformation.
“Visitors felt the lash of Sarah’s scorn. They feared to acknowledge that they could not understand. They were afraid not to consent, some of their opinions might turn out to be important. They would have liked to include themselves as one of the early messengers of a new gospel. They wished that the canvases did not offend them so painfully. They tried to like them, but for all their effort, they could not escape the suspicion that they were being hypnotised by the Steins. Once out in the open, free from the barrage of Mrs. Stein’s personal charm and the fluency of her arguments, they feared a return to their freedom.
They were afraid of the brilliant canvases – of their unorthodoxy. They couldn’t bear the violence of them. They were afraid to buy them, they were afraid not to buy them. Afraid that they would turn out to be the important paintings the Steins said they were.”
This short paragraph sums up everything one might ever say about the brilliance of Picasso and Matisse. The outrageous character of their iconoclasm was certainly capable of mesmerising and at the same time terrorizing viewers. There was nothing to back up the sentiments of these early admirers (given, perhaps, to more settled, easier works) apart from the incredible force of the two sisters who worked with the insistence of apostles promoting a new religion.

Sarah Stein has not been as celebrated as her sister, Gertrude.
In fact, her name doesn't appear at all on the plaque mounted on the facade of
27 Rue de Fleurus, where she too resided, along with the other Steins,
before going down the religious path of her later years.
Source: Wikipedia
And so, if I had to choose a person to whose memory to raise a monument, that person would certainly be, to my mind and my convictions, Sarah Stein. She managed to make room in the hearts of art buyers and art lovers; she mowed the overgrowth of insecurity from their alveoli and planted, into the freshly exposed soil, the seeds of what I like to call the ‘Age of Matisse.’

No comments:

Post a Comment